They found that anxiety state was not significantly affected—increase or decrease—by the complementary music therapy, but pain control and environmental noise satisfaction was increased with use of the therapy. Running Head: Research critique- Nursing care perspectives. These findings offer insights into the potential benefits of a more highly educated nurse workforce. They include the results and a summary of conclusions from these findings. Adhering to Ethical Standards 6. Quantitative research is a formal, objective, systematic process in which numerical data are used to obtain information about the world Burns and Grove, 2007.
Our findings provide sobering evidence that this imbalance may be harming patients. The research question for this study was does job related stress lead to higher rates of sick absence, long-term and short-term as well as higher frequency?. The resources used are more for the definition of caring and to support the need of further research and not that of the specific topic of lamentation and loss expressed among surgical nurses Enns, 2007. This highlights the danger of institutions making practice recommendations on the basis of the findings of one, unreplicated study, especially if the study involved has serious biases and flaws in methodology. This is not a null hypothesis, though the null hypothesis is implied though not stated. Thus, being able to explain the causes of such stress, its relationships with other variables, and the means through which stress can be alleviated are important considerations in nursing research.
Were they any threats to external validity or internal validity? Sample observations are then used to estimate specific population parameters. Critique of Quantitative and Qualitative Research Articles assignment examples. Are the suggestions for future action based on practical significance or on statistical significance only, i. Note up to 10 points can be deducted for going over or under the page requirements for the Critique of Quantitative and Qualitative Research Articles assignment examples. Include an Introduction section entitled, Critique of Quantitative and Qualitative Articles centered, not bolded , that indicates the purpose of your paper b.
Contributing to the stress are the psychological aspects, and the coping ability of the nurses, job demands such as workload, time pressure, and role conflict were highlighted by the authors. The design was able to draw causal inferences about the relationship between the independent and dependent variables, despite little attention to the external factors to the study. Part 1: quantitative research to critiquing quantitative research to help nurses demystify the. Results showed that there were 912 and 910 participants in the control and intervention groups, respectively. As these are established research data collection tools, this would suggest they have been previously validated, which adds to the quality of the research Yu and Cooper, 1983 p 36; Oppenheim, 1992; McDowell and Newell, 1996; McColl et al, 2001 p 1.
This essay evaluates a quantitative research article which has relevance to nursing practice, because it deals with a chronic condition and one which is prevalent in worldwide populations. The extent, amount and nature of publications accessible today by different… 1974 Words 8 Pages Nursing research has been a part of nursing practice for many years, consisting of both qualitative and quantitative research; it is essential in guiding nursing practice. College The performance of English learners is a serious issue that must be looked upon. Are the control procedures described? The methods and results proved to be accurate yielding high confidence intervals. American Journal of Critical Care, 24 3 , 199-209.
Introduction and Literature Review Although Cormack 2000 separates these two into distinct subheadings, within this article, the introduction and literature review are contiguous. These, according to qualitative researchers, can be applied to qualitative approaches. What did the qualitative researchers do to ensure rigor in their study? Stress levels are different for each individual and handled differently by all, one thing that is evident across the board and emphasized by the study is that stress is prolific in healthcare and I nursing, Conclusion In conclusion the findings in this study showed that the combination of the two formulas comprised the most reliable analysis of the data leading to the conclusion that stress has an effect on nursing absenteeism. Findings of this investigation may also help future test-takers in determining the type of preparatory programs and courses that they should take in. What remains unknown is whether or not optimism can be considered as a significant mediating element in the context of the relationship between perceived stress and health-promoting behaviors among primiparous mothers.
Quantitative Research Critique Essay Sample Abstract The critique of the study on job-related stress and sickness absence among Belgian nurses was conducted on the studies validity and reliability. All custom papers are prepared by qualified writers according to your instructions and, therefore, exclude any chance of plagiarism. If a pilot study was conducted, are its execution and results described as well as its impact on the subsequent study? They highlight some important topics in relation to the focus of the article, including treatment, social support, and other issues Tangkawanich et al, 2008 p 216. For example, what statistical tests were performed by the quantitative researchers and for what purpose where they used? · In your own words what methods and procedures were used? The major problem identified is that of funding. When necessary, are variables directly or operationally defined? The study concludes that nurses fail to execute their roles effectively due to certain. It is also apparent that social factors may outweigh medical factors, other than in the provision of antiretroviral therapies for these patients. Is there a statement of the problem? The relevance of this study was not clearly established by the researchers, since no gap in the research was presented, though the importance of this experiment was supported by the findings of the research.
Data was collected three times during the study—Time One being first postoperative day, following 24 hours later consecutively for Time Two and Three. For the qualitative article, address the transferability of the findings. Review the three categories below highlighted , which include one quantitative and one qualitative article. Is the educational significance of the problem discussed? Methods for Data Analysis 5. Instead, the authors only described the research aims. The research indicates the significance of inadvertent hypothermia among nurses.
American Journal of Critical Care, 26 6 , 438-444. Questions will arise to clarify about who are the rater involved, and level of expertise were similar or different. American Journal of Critical Care, 26 6 , 438-444. Summarization 20 10% Summarize your own thoughts regarding the usefulness of quantitative and quantitative research when making a change in practice. Quantitative research approaches offer a better standards of evidence, with generally greater ability for replication and greater rigour Kitson et al, 2000 p 149; Duffy, 2005, p 233. The researchers then found a way to evaluate levels of. Directions and Grading Criteria Category Points % Description Introduction 10 5% Introduction paragraph is concise approximately 5 sentences.